If you trade that much for Wilkerson and Livian, I doubt you have enoug trade bullets left to get Dunn or Abreu. You'd be left to trying to sign Giles or looking at other targets. You think the Cubs are giving up too much in that deal? When I wrote it I figured I would get the response of "That isn't enough to get it done." I would say the only (potentially) major loss in that trade is Hill, and I'm far from sold on him. I never said you were giving up too much, just when we do that deal, we won't have the right players left to get a Dunn or Abreu. You don't think the Reds would get enough in this deal: Cubs get: Dunn Twins get: Walker Reds get: Pie, JC Romero, Jerome Williams I think it could be done. It won't, but it could be done. I think the Reds are getting enough, but the Cubs are giving up too much.