Ahh gotcha. I see what you're saying now. I interpreted your post differently.
Shaw got 131 AB's at AAA and was pretty dominant. I'm also pro keep Shaw at the MLB level but I also dont think hes struggling as much as it looks. I think he's holding his own and consistently has good AB's. His walk rate is great and I think its just a matter of time before he starts barreling the ball. I do think having Shaw up right now is a bit of a necessity that pushed this type of development forward though. Let say we had signed Bregman for example, we are probably watching Shaw dominate AAA right now rather than cut his teeth and come along slowly at the MLB level, similar to what the Cubs did with Bellinger and PCA.
I guess that's just kind of where the eye test comes into play and your scouting idk. I just think there is a lot of value at AAA that might be untapped but I do see the value in your point.