Consistently? I hope I am, but I think most of the time he'll be hovering below 2. Certainly could be a lot worse, but I think he's just too vulnerable against LH pitching and not damaging enough against RH pitching. I know it seems like most here hate BR's defensive metrics, but I was thinking of their 2012 rating for him when I said that. I don't think he'll regularly be ranked that high, but I think his defense is more likely than his offense to sharpen up at this point. go read all that stuff North posted a while back about rizzo again. i think there's a lot of reason to think anthony ends up a solidly above average offensive first baseman. castro i have no idea how what to think he'll do going forward.