You know who else had a proven track record of "not being terrible"? Bob Howry. Exept for 2008 of course. Furthurmore, Weurtz wasn't even terrible when he was demoted, our manager just has ADD. Howry minus 5 outings this year: 47.1 IP, 3.58 ERA, 1.15 WHIP, 35/7 K/BB Those numbers are absolutely atrocious given that you've removed his worst 5 outings. If you take all of the other relievers in the league that have 30+ outings this year, and you remove their 5 worst appearances, those numbers would probably rank in the bottom 20% of the league. Many mediocre relievers would have an ERA in the low 2s if you removed their 5 worst appearances. If you removed Wuertz's 5 worst outings this year, his line is: 35.2IP, 4 ER, 1.01 ERA, 1.07 WHIP, 23/12 K/BB, far superior to Howry's, other than he's walking a few more people. Even if you only removed two of his outings instead of five, his numbers are: 36.2 IP, 8 ER, 1.99 ERA, 24/14 K/BB. Let's apply a little perspective to this argument...Both Howry and Wuertz have been solid to outstanding relievers from 2005-2007. Wuertz is going on 30, Howry is 6 years older. It is more likely that Wuertz's problems this year are an anomoly rather than a decline due to age. Howry, however, is the opposite case. There's more room for optimism that Wuertz can regroup and perform well the rest of the year than there is for Howry. Wuertz despite his "struggles" is performing almost perfectly in line with his career numbers. That said, I'd like to see consecutive good outings from him at Iowa to ensure there's nothing wrong with him, mentally or otherwise, before bringing him back up. If he can do that, I'd be shopping Howry or DFAing him at that point.