I see alot of negative on Shaw, which is ok, but let remember he's a rookie who struggled most of the season outside of a good second half run. He's 0 for 12 with 4 walks in postseason.
I think if you really want to blast hitters it should be the veterans and guys who has played in the postseason.
Happ on base 4 times total, Tucker had a big game tonight, on base 8 times total, Suzuki on base 6 times total, Swanson on base 6 times total, and Kelly on base 5 times total, haven't exactly been that much better overall.
Shaw may not have a hit but he has reached base and going into tonight his OBP was better than 5 of the above, only Kelly was better.
I didn't include PCA cause he's a rookie too, but he's reached base 5 times and Shaw OBP was better than his too.