False, especially regarding Brendan Ryan. Skip is pretty average, but Fangraph's had him valued at $5.4 last year, with a salary of $0.8. He's getting a raise this year in arbitration, but I'd expect his value to still be a bit more than what the Cards are paying him. Ryan, on the other hand, was worth $14.2, making just $0.4, making him an excellent value based mostly on his stellar defense. hooray for more fangraphs figures. i don't believe that brendan ryan was worth 14 million dollars last season. also, that same formula had him as worthless before last season. so is he 2009 brendan ryan? i just don't like how it's now commonplace to look at a fangraphs value figure and say "_____ was worth ______ dollars last season" like it's a fact oh well, maybe saying they suck was a bit strong. my popint was just that i don't think you can look at brendan ryan and skip schumaker and say "well, we're tying up a ton of money elsewhere, but we're set at these positions for a while"