Gorzelanny has a significantly higher upside than Hart. Ascanio will likely be better than Grabow in the long term, but Grabow will probably help us more this year. As for giving up Marquis - his replacement in the rotation, Randy Wells, has better numbers than Marquis this season. Marquis: 3.47 ERA; 64:41 K:BB; 1.267 WHIP Wells: 2.84 ERA; 60:21 K:BB; 1.147 WHIP But, but you left out the most important stat: Marquis has more wins....oh, and he was an All Star too!!! Even if this was meant to be serious, Marquis really only has more wins because of our horrible bullpen and the fact that Wells hasn't had as many starts. I should've used green font