That doesn't mean he wasn't really smart. Couldn't he have really good command, movement, AND be a very smart pitcher? I don't see why not. I don't think he's denying Maddux's intelligence, he's just stating, correctly, that oftentimes, Maddux's stuff is overlooked. All his intelligence, sans good stuff, wouldn't have gotten Maddux to several Cy Youngs, 300+ wins, & the Hall of Fame