In the postgame interview, Eddings said he makes the same motion for every strikeout, whether the ball hits the ground or not. This is a lie. The previous batter, Aaron Rowand, struck out on a ball that bounced. Eddings made no motion until Josh Paul tagged or threw Rowand out (don't know which happened). Josh Paul said in his postgame interview that every umpire says, including Eddings, "not caught" when strike 3 is not caught. Eddings acknowledged he did not say that it was not caught. When asked why not, he said something to the extent that he wanted to see what the players did. It's obvious that ALL the Angels saw the same thing, since they all were walking off the field. I would think a few, especially Erstad, Kennedy or Escobar might have thought otherwise if there was any question - but there wasn't, since Eddings ruled AJP out TWICE.