Emery's problem is that he is crappy at identifying talent, not that he went after guys he liked. I'm pretty sure McLellin was the top guy on his board when he picked him. GM's reach for people all the time based on who they like and who will be there when they pick next. Optimally, you want to get the guy you like, where they're slotted, but most settle for who they want. Trying to determine if a guy was best on a GMs board is a project in vain because draft boards vary so much. (This goes for Angelo or Emery) Retrospectively with Emery, he seemed to be a very process oriented guy, which is only a good thing if you have the right process in place. He seems like a decent scout, but was obviously a poor GM. Angelo... obviously had some early hits and then not only failed to follow up on that success, but also systematically devalued the draft and develepment pipeline.