It's an interesting situation. I remember, back in 2003 when the Braves started Ortiz on short rest, all these stats were coming out about how pitchers usually do pretty poorly when their teams bring them out on short rest. Obviously, it makes complete logical sense. On the other hand, though, Z is the type of guy who has seemed to do worse when he's too fresh and pumped up. He loses the sink and starts throwing harder and higher and giving up more fly balls. Maybe it's just perception, but I know I'm not the only one who has the same impression. Playoffs, opening days, coming off extra rest, etc.. On the other hand, Z didn't do all that great when he pitched on short rest earlier this month. So it could be moot. So, I guess the question is... Is Z on short rest in game 4 > gambling on Marquis showing up in Game 4 and having a fresher Z in a potential game 5?