One of em is Jonah Keri, editor and contributor to Baseball Between the Numbers. I might have to pick up the book. I always meant to and forgot about it. http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0465005969 Heh, I was looking at reviews for that book, and I found a pretty funny one. Pretty much mirrors a common theme on this board. At the very least, one of the more well spoken arguments against the numbers I've seen, although he did have to resort to the "pencil necked geeks," line. At least he (almost) admits (or at least, seems to suggest) that the reason he doesn't like the numbers is that he wants to keep some of the mystery and sort of innocence of the game in tact.