Here's the problem with trying to use this: Womack didn't have a Bonds-esque season, as you make it sound like. His OPS on the season was 30 points higher that Eckstien's career average. Yet it was still easily the best season of Womack's career, at age 34. 2002 (with Pittsburgh): .94 WHIP, .161 BAA, 2.65 ERA 2003 (with Yankees): 1.29 WHIP, .201 BAA, 3.18 ERA 2005 (with Cardinals): .91 WHIP, .175 BAA, 2.54 ERA Why can't you say that 2003 was a fluke from his recent history? 2002: 17 IP 2003: 17 IP 2004: 12 IP 2005: 46 IP Reyes has pitched as many innings this year as the last 3 years combined. He hasn't been within 20 innings of this year's total since 1999. The point remains is that the Cardinals have consistently gotten players to overachieve. Some of that can be attributed to coaching, some to luck. How much of each we'll never know. However, you can't deny the good fortunes of the Cards the last few years as they have had significantly better W-L records than their performance should have dictated.