raw
Community Moderator-
Posts
5,716 -
Joined
-
Days Won
7
Content Type
Profiles
Chicago Cubs Videos
Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors
2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings
Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis
2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources
2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Blogs
Events
Forums
Store
Gallery
Everything posted by raw
-
Seems to be all about the gameplan to me. Super conservative early in games. Consistently try to establish Montgomery early to predictability. And like has been mentioned, there seems like there'll be a big 3rd down conversion on a 10+ yard pass and then they go into wildcat. It takes until the Bears are inevitably down until they actually start trying to score points. Then they're just not good enough at it for it to matter.
-
Man this game had everything. I truly didn't care about the result of the game, but I was completely pissed at the first half officiating. I mean, Bears are bad, shorthanded, and you still screw them over? Not that they would have won the game, but I hate that anger took over my ambivalence at one point. It also had classic Nagy, Nagying. I'm not a big play call guy, but clearly short yardage and 4th down plays are laughable. Situational game management is deplorable. If the world didn't know how bad he is as a coach, they know now. Fields gets in a rhythm, throw in wildcat. Hurry up offense is moving the ball, let's make them huddle up and throw a dive in here. Fields was bad, then he was good. I feel like the ability to throw the ball downfield with accuracy is one of the most important things a QB can do well to help his team. But he has to fix the little things. Stop taking dumb sacks. And for the love of God, protect the damn ball. Way too many fumbles. But when he throws it, it's a thing of beauty. Just needs some help. Nobody is making any above average plays for him. If the ball isn't perfectly placed, nobody is making a catch (Kmet misses perfectly placed ones as well). Guys seem to be just a couple steps off of where Fields expects them to be. And based on reactions, I think Fields is the one doing his job right. Saw some good things from Jenkins and Graham was amazing. Even guys like Marqui Christian and Teez Tabor stepped up. I'd love to see Desai get another shot at DC with a healthy Mack and a revamped DB room, but probably not happening with a new staff. I don't think he's the next Brandon Staley or anything just yet, but I do think he has some potential as a dC.
-
FWIW, I love going for the W there. Harbaugh isn't going to say it, but they aren't beating Rodgers in OT if he touches the ball. I know they stopped them the 2 previous drives, but the ones before that he was unstoppable as usual.
-
It's a good point... Fields could be having standard rookie struggles AND be greatly held back by terrible coaching/team, which would dip him into historically poor numbers relative to other QBs. Not to say that other rookies haven't had bad coaching, but its a bit of a unique situation. Also again it's 9 games. He does have some things he needs to work on but if you parse the numbers out, he's doing some things well and has shown enough flashes to keep my faith high. If he's still in this range this time next year, then sure I'll be concerned. Isn't Mac Jones the only rookie with good ratings? Fields catches a lot of flack compared to Wilson and Lawrence who are seemingly playing about the same level. The numbers I'm basing this on may be a touch out of date, but I remember reading this a few weeks earlier in the season. Yeah, Wilson and Lawrence are literally at the same level. Fields and Lawrence literally have the same QB rating and the same mess from an offensive talent/coaching standpoint (though Lawrence's is ugly bad). Wilson's slightly lower, but seems to have the most stable coaching situation.
-
Go for 2 or not, the play calls on these things is what kills teams. You cut off half the field, and like you said, the first read for a rolling QB is the only WR that is in his current line of sight. If you have a mobile QB, you want to give them the option to run. On the goal line, the best way to do that is to spread the defense out. You can give him 1 read and then let him go, and then if something pops open he can throw it once you get the defense moving. But the way that play was designed, he would have had to either stop or completely flip his head to the middle, which allows the pass rush to potentially get there.
-
Nope. Every player on the roster counts. Practice squad too. Nah, salary cap only counts top 53 highest paid players.
-
Going for it on 4th inside the 5 going in to halftime I felt was kinda stupid. Could’ve gone up 7, didn’t get the benefit of field position if you don’t get it and then can stop the Chiefs where you at least can get the ball back around the 50. The other 4th down attempts all seemed reasonable to me though. I disagree with this too. IDK if the Chargers were underdogs or not, but I know they were behind in the division. They needed this win in order to stay alive for a playoff home game. They should be throwing out all the stops and going for the W. I'd understand if they were getting the ball back after halftime and had 2 shots to score before the Chiefs touched the ball again, but I particularly loved this decision more than all the others, just because most teams would have just taken the 3 and been OK with it. Top 5 offense should be able to get 3 yards.
-
Yea, the 2 pt analytic wave hasn't even really hit yet even though many coaches have gotten better on the 4th down analytics. Except for of course our own Matt Nagy. Addendum to that. Actually I'm okay going up 8 in that situation. Still value in forcing the 2PTA and if you do go up 9 you just signal KC to go into hurry up. But it seems to be one of those close call situations from a model sense. Nah, I'd rather KC is in hurry up. Mahomes had been prone to mistakes the last few weeks and even earlier in that game. Also, I think you have to take into account how good each offense is, in general. You have a top 5 offense in LA, going against a top 5 offense. You "trust your defense" but you also give them any wiggle room you can get. You have to operate under the assumption that the Chiefs (a top 3 offense themselves) will be able to score. You also are in the 4th quarter, so you trust that either your offense can control the clock (with likely a 2pt lead if you go up 9) or they can score again if KC ties it. The difference between 7 and 8 is KC has to make 1 more play. The difference between 7 and 9 is KC has to make 1 more DRIVE, with the clock on your side.
-
Ironically, the failure to be aggressive probably hurt their chances to win more than the opposite. 14-13 Chargers lead. Score a TD to go up 20-13, they kick the PAT instead of going for 2. That kept it a 1-score game, 21-13. If they go for 2 and get it, they're up 9 and the Chiefs have to score twice (which they did), but they'd also need two 2pt conversions once the Chargers scored again late. If they go for 2 and they fail, they're up 7 and the game is tied anyway as the Chiefs just kick PATs and don't have to go for 2 unless they are being super aggressive. So, there was really no difference between being up 7 or 8 points in the long run.
-
But wait, it gets worse.
-
Noooo I want to see a Matt Nagy coached game without any of his coaches and calling plays so I can hate watch. First Nagy screws up the headsets, now he gave Lazor Covid just so he can call plays.....that maniacal bastard!
-
Part of me wonders if Meyer tried to get fired so he could pocket 50Mil for just 13 games of work. NFL coaching contracts are guaranteed, unless they are fired for cause (outside of wins and losses). Definitely seems like conduct issues worthy of cause to fire him and not pay him the remainder of his contract. But that could also lead to an ugly lawsuit. Wonder how the money is going to play out. But damn, you can't kick players, ditch your team to get grinded on at the bar, call your coach losers and blame them for stuff that didn't happen, all while being a failure on the field including potentially ruining the best QB prospect in a decade. I knew he was a piece of horsefeathers, but damn. Also, Jags almost HAVE to hire Leftwich right? One, he's a top coaching candidate and happens to be the OC of an elite offense which would fit very well with TLaw's skillset. Second, Meyer was hired at 10-12Mil/season reportedly, Leftwich would be much cheaper without HC experience and not a huge name. Third, he was a former well-loved Jag QB and the team could really use some good PR to create goodwill with their fan base.
-
yea. Its puzzling why the Bears didnt just play spy with Adams/Johnson. IIRC, in the first meeting JJ followed Adams to the slot and didn't have the same success as he did on the outside. Slot corner is talked about like a different position and I can see how it would be. JJ appears to be best as a boundary corner. Someone with more in depth football knowledge than me might be able to explain why beyond just being in the middle of the field. Man, I literally said this in the quoted post. LOL But yeah, outside vs. slot CB can be very different. The outside guy has the sideline on his side, so he can use that in his coverage technique to his advantage. The slot guy has a 2-way go. The WR could go on an in-breaking route or an outside route, so the slot requires a guy with more change of direction skill and enough hip flexibility to turn either way with the WR.
-
COVID has struck the Bears again. The only thing anyone in the organization can catch. Bears have put their OC (Lazor), DC (Desai) and ST coordinator (Tabor) in Covid protocol. Along with the following players already on the list: Eddie Goldman- for I believe the 3rd time this year, and he very wisely (sarcasm) isn't vaccinated after sitting out 2020 Larry Borom Mario Edwards Sam Kamara Elijah Wilkinson Artie Burns They have had no in person contact this week due to the outbreak. With 2 OTs on the Covid list and Peters not healthy, Germain Ifedi (not even sure what his injury was) is ironically ready to go by Monday night according to Nagy.
-
Yeah, this was always the thought with JSU hiring him. I don't know if the end game is Deion getting a Power 5 job or if it's the SWAC to become a power conference. I'm really hoping it's the latter because it will really shake horsefeathers up if black players in the South have a legit chance for exposure at HBCUs. I can’t see SWAC ever becoming a power conference. They just don’t have the money. In fact, it was a big deal this year when Jackson State players had their names on the backs of their jerseys because in the SWAC they have to reuse jerseys year to year. I believe Deion paid for that out of his own pocket. I mean, if they get all the top athletes to come to the conference, they'll get on TV (TV deals) and then they'll have money. But yeah, it's a long shot.
-
That's about to change. If Deion (and other SWAC schools) continue to get top commits, that'll force stations to televise them. There are rumors flying that he's taking his bag to get a few other top guys, too, so this should be interesting. Yeah, this was always the thought with JSU hiring him. I don't know if the end game is Deion getting a Power 5 job or if it's the SWAC to become a power conference. I'm really hoping it's the latter because it will really shake horsefeathers up if black players in the South have a legit chance for exposure at HBCUs.
-
To be fair, the Bears did have Johnson following Adams around the first time they played. Johnson was similarly good on the outside and got beat pretty handily in the slot. But IDC if you have to change your whole defense, you can't let DeVante Adams roam all over the field and face man coverage with Xavier Crawford, or LBs or a safety. If he beats Johnson (joke here) from the slot, then so be it. Get beat with your best on their best.
-
Seems to me like I saw them on TV a bunch last season. Maybe I'm dreaming that. I think you are. They've been featured on TV commercials because of Deion doing Geico with Saban now, but SWAC games are rarely televised. That's about to change. If Deion (and other SWAC schools) continue to get top commits, that'll force stations to televise them.
-
There were several plays sunday night where the GB defender took 2-3 steps as Fields was releasing the ball and still hit/tackled him. I'm used to it by now, but it seems like the refs let opposing D's tee off on him I guess in the NFL you have to survive long enough as a QB to start getting the calls. Until then, the risk of a career-limiting injury is way higher. That's how it seems anyway. There's a theory that many of these calls are mobile/immobile related. Mobile QBs universally believe that they don't get the calls that the pocket guys get. Cam Newton has always complained about it, and still isn't getting the calls at his veteran age. But the mobile QBs not getting roughing call thing leads to the potential of racially motivated calls, which I'm sure the league isn't ready to admit. I wonder if there's a statistic for how many roughing calls each QB has gotten. I'd be interested to see how guys like Herbert, Allen, and Mayfield compare to Lamar, Kyler and others.
-
yea, that was above and beyond. even my wife (who hates all things sports and especially football) raised her head and eloquently made your point by saying something like "this is why I hate football, these announcers sound like they live in Green Bay. Aaron Rodgers is a lying piece of horsefeathers" For the record, whenever anyone has "horsefeathers" in a quote, I like to really imagine the person (your wife in this case) actually using the word horsefeathers. Makes every post funnier.
-
We can expect perfect decisions, not perfect results. It's not even hard decisions. I was pissed he didn't go for 4th on the opening drive at the 40. I wasn't happy he kicked the 1st FG on 4th down from the 3. It was just asinine to punt the ball on 4th and inches down 11. It's not like they were in the shadows of the goal line either. You were 4-8 and getting fired. Why are you not playing to win? You're going to lose if you punt the ball to a QB that scored every time he touched the ball after the 1st quarter. Everyone expects you to lose, take risks. If you lose, so be it, you were supposed to anyway.
-
I don't buy that they are putting him in any danger. He hasn't taken the amount of abuse to where he will be shellshocked from getting hit in the future. He also isn't really developing any unfixable habits. If he doesn't turn out to be a good QB it's because he can't play, not because a coach ruined him in a span of 13 games.
-
I'm done talking about playcalling. It kinda is what it is at this point. I think we saw last year with Mitch when literally the only thing they could do with him is move the pocket around, that Green Bay can stop that. Sure they aren't playing towards Fields' strengths, but timing routes is stuff he needs to be able to do and work on, this year is just a learning process. Hopefully he is better at those things when a real offense needs him to do those in the future. I thought Fields played OK. The pick 6 was bad. A couple high throws. I thought the high ball to Grant was more due to Grant slipping out of his break and the throw was mostly fine. Robinson made a great catch on a high one, that would have been a 1st down if it was a better throw (play before the 4th and short punt, IIRC). The INT at the end to Mooney was a bit high, but I'd like to see these guys start making plays. Not a great throw, but catchable. Robinson had shitty effort on a few of his targets as well. Kmet with a couple drops. Montgomery dropped one. Byrd could have had better awareness on the sideline incompletion (high throw to get over the defender). Just really tough to evaluate Justin right now because of the coaching and talent. The talent isn't going to get much better next year (possibly worse as you will downgrade from what ARob is supposed to be), so Fields is going to have to take the next step. Can't complain much about 23 points put up with what he has to work with. Probably puts up more if he has a better coaching staff who goes for it on 4th and inches or from the oppo 40 and of course if the game wasn't over and they weren't forced to go on 4th late.
-
Yeah, the Bulls asked for a postponement and the league was like, "Nah. Suit up." I mean, I know it's Detroit, but a team of NBA players will destroy Lonzo, Vooch, 85% healthy Caruso and G-leaguers. And the Bulls have no business losing to Detroit in a normal circumstance
-
He looked like a rookie playing his first game. I thought he did well in the 1st half. Had a few penalties. False start? It happens. Holding calls? The one on the strip sack, he held for like a 1/2 second. He grabbed then tried to get his hands away quickly and just kind of let the guy go completely. Should have just continued the hold (probably didn't know he got caught) and lived to play another play. The one on the WR screen where he was lined out wide, I thought was weak. He probably held, but he was just mauling a little DB. It always looks like holding when a 320lb guy dominates someone 190. On the 2nd sack he gave up (and on at least 1 other pressure/QB hit) he seemed to be screwed up by the lack of a chip block from RB. He seemed to be waiting on Montgomery to get the chip and then engage in his block. Monty barely touched the guy and Jenkins looked like he was waiting around for the chip to happen first, by the time he realized the chip wasn't happening, the defender had him beat.

