Jump to content
North Side Baseball

raw

Community Moderator
  • Posts

    5,716
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by raw

  1. I feel like teams are always vague with QBs. Like the Ravens haven't even said what Lamar did to his thumb, even though we could see it turned the wrong way. They haven't said he's out for the year, just said will have surgery. Cincy has done similar with Burrow. Philly was very non-committal to the Hurts injury for the first week. It's always "week to week" or "out for the season" with a QB just because of the nature of that position. At least with Kmet, we have been told he's done for the season, even though "ACL tear" hasn't been thrown out there officially.
  2. The Bears haven't really been together since the injury though. They stayed in Seattle overnight and flew back yesterday. No practices/meetings have happened. Theo played thru the injury and never left the field. IDK how many beat guys were in the lockeroom or even paying attention (Bears beat isn't the best). I just think there hasn't been an opportunity for an update/reporting.
  3. THIS WAS ALWAYS THE WAY. All the nerdy analysis during the offseason was that the Bears were a big regression candidate. - "They aren't going to lead the league in takeaways again!" - "They won 7 one-score games, they aren't going to get that luck again!" - "The 4th quarter comebacks are unsustainable!" - "They didn't add pass rush help!" While those were legitimate concerns from the outside looking in, I think anyone that watched this team last year could see that these conversations needed to be had with a lot more nuance. The Bears got off to pretty slow starts last year. They were playing from behind a lot while trying to learn one of the most detailed oriented offenses in the league. Two of the top 4 pass catchers were rookies. Rookie at RB. 4 new offensive linemen. This was a team that got better as the game went on, and performed a lot better when they could stop sweating the details and just try to get points in a hurry....which just so happened to be what they did best. I went back and looked at all of the turnovers from last year. I can't remember where I put the data, but the more of the Bears turnovers took points OFF the board, rather than put points ON the board. Again, a nuanced conversation. The Bears actually weren't given a bunch of short fields from their turnovers. Over 1/2 the turnovers they took away were when the opponents were in FG range. So obviously, the turnovers were a huge factor, and they were winning because of the takeaways, but it was always a scenario where just getting actual stops 1 or 2 times per game would make up for the lack of takeaways. Also, turnovers are a lot less necessary to get, when you don't turn the ball over yourself. Caleb is literally the best QB in NFL history at keeping the ball out of harm's way. He doesn't throw picks. He doesn't fumble much. So to win turnover margins the Bears didn't have to keep up a historic level of INTs. Just needed a fumble here. A pick there. A banana punt getting muffed every few weeks. And while the Bears did win 8 one-score games (including playoffs), they were actually a very modest 8-5 in those games. This year they are 2-1 in one-score games. One in the monsoon, with Caleb tearing his hamstring while assumingly taking the lead. The 2 wins were games the Bears otherwise dominated vs Atlanta and New England, and never actually trailed....but ended with a 1 score difference. Clearly, a different formula to end up with around the same result. And that formula was always the key. You don't need 4th quarter comebacks if you play with the lead. I'd argue it was an anomaly that the Bears even needed comebacks with the fact that they had the league's best run game. Teams that lead the league in rush are usually those teams that are playing with leads. Of the Bears 19 games last year, they played with the lead the majority of the game, only 6 times. So theoretically, a strong run game and a QB that doesn't turn the ball over, and 11 guys on the field that are in Year 2 of a difficult offense should be able get leads early and hold onto to them, because they aren't going to beat themselves by turning the ball over or being forced to throw the ball around like GB is right now. And the run game hasn't even been THAT good the last few weeks without Monangai. While there is still a long way to go this season and the Bears could certainly still miss the playoffs if they don't beat division teams, it looks like the expectations of the Bears' demise were greatly exaggerated. And I'm feeling big "I told you so" energy. Oh, and now they have pass rush help too!
  4. FWIW, Theo was seen with a big ice pack on his shoulder after the game. I saw someone getting interviewed and Theo walked by looking like Quasimodo. So I think the shoulder separation is real. Nicholas Moreano heard him literally say the words "separated shoulder" to someone. Guessing we'll get details today the injury report coming out, though I believe there is just a walk thru, if even that.
  5. Gervon Dexter wore 99 until 2 months ago. And also the 3 full seasons before that. It's been worn every year but 2 since Hampton retired
  6. Just posting here to say that I can't believe my school is reigning National Champions. Still gotta pinch myself. Also, back-to-back coming, bitches
  7. While I hate losing a 24 year old player on a cheap rookie deal just on principle.....it's weird to me to be like "oh man, this DL sucked last year and on paper sucks again this year", but then be phased at all by losing the guy who got the most snaps on that terrible DL from last year and is the prettiest DL in an ugly contest this year. Jordan Van Den Berg is killing it in camp. A lot of those snaps Dexter vacates will go to him. In the preseason game, when Dexter got pressure on the QB, if you notice, JVDB is the guy that ate the double team to free him. Allen likes to slant and stunt his DL and Dexter simply doesn't move fast enough for the Bears to do that effectively with him on the field. Also, it seems like Allen has put a TON of emphasis on stopping the run this year. While I know they aren't playing #1 OLs, throughout the depth chart they are stopping the run. Even while getting destroyed on teh scoreboard last week, they only allowed 64 rush yards on 20 carries. Week 1 of preseason, they allowed 108 on 27 carries, but 50 of those yards came on 2 of the last 3 carries of the game when the insurance salesmen were playing. Dexter notoriously isn't great against the run. There's a ton of writing on the wall. And I get it, weakening a weak group seems bad on paper. But is there ever going to be a point this season where we are like "damn, if only we kept Dexter!"?
  8. My opinion is, if you aren't going to sign him long-term after this year (and they certainly should NOT), then get something for him. I know it's not great but Jarrett, Gallimore, Van Den Berg, Street and Lynch (looked good in preseason) isn't that much different than that same group with Dexter and no Lynch. At least without Dexter, you have 5 guys who all fit what Dennis Allen wants. Ideally, you get stronger at DE or DB by trading Dexter. But getting a draft pick (I will assume a 5th, late 4 at best) for him wouldn't be the worst thing either.
  9. Pants and helmet make them work. Just saw the jersey first and was not a fan. Definitely getting Syracuse vibes though.
  10. Caleb said that miss to Loveland was a blown coverage and he saw it right away. It looks like he just rushed it because he didn't want to take a hit.....which is understandable in a fake game he probably didn't want to play. In a real game, he probably stands in there and takes another 1/2 second to hit that throw.
  11. When I'm in charge of the NFL, we will go to 18 game regular seasons with 2 bye weeks per team. And no preseason games. Scrimmages and joint practices will be encouraged and televised the way preseason is. I think it's a good way to boost fan interest as most people don't get to go to training camp practices and have no idea what they actually entail. Also, non-degenerates don't watch preseason games in full, so you'd bring in viewership by knowing that starters will be out there playing/practicing.
  12. Loveland most catches Burden most yards Rome most TDs
  13. I'm partial to Haasan Reddick. Youngest of the group, I'd guess and kind of the anti-Dennis Allen player. But also, Kayvon Thibodeaux and Josh Sweat are potentially on the trade market.
  14. In counting stats, sure. But Loveland was much more efficient, more explosive, and a much better blocker by all metrics.
  15. There were 8 TEs drafted in a 40 picks with the Bears' Roush pick right in the middle of that run. The Rams actually ran the most 12/13 personnel in the league. And McVay is in that Shanahan tree. So is about 1/3 of the playcallers in the league. So that's why you saw a bunch of TEs this year. And the TE position has typically been a position where you don't get great production right away. But with guys like Loveland, Warren and Bowers early production; teams are naturally valuing the position higher. While they may not get that level of players, they aren't going to stop chasing that.
  16. In general, they hit all the positions I thought they would, except Edge. The big issue is the overall big picture. Like you can't just keep saying "we didn't like any of the DL in this class" or "we didn't have any guys we liked fall to us". Well, Poles has shown the willingness to trade up. He traded up for Tyrique Stevenson and this year for Muhammad and Vanderberg. So he definitely has the ability to identify a guy he wants and go get him. I just don't know why he doesn't "go get him" when that guy is in the trenches constantly. Poles has got to show more foresight. If there's even a remote chance you don't come out of Day 2 with DL help, then you HAVE to do more in free agency or on the trade front. I understand people gave up astronomical amounts for Crosby and then Dexter Lawrence, but the lack of a plan B/C is hurting Poles, IMO. And I understand that Dayo/Grady took away a lot of ability to really make a big splash there in free agency, but then you gotta do more to identify and get your guy in the draft. And I will appreciate the fact that the focus early in the draft has been getting and supporting your QB. But you've had a clear weakness since 2022 when Brisker led the team with 4 sacks. Poles has made the effort, but with Sweat, Dayo, Grady, Dexter, Pickens, Ngakoue, Darrell Taylor, whatever, but it's clearly still not good enough. You can't keep missing opportunities to make it good enough. Whether it's more draft capital, better scouting, more aggressive trading, or more wise free agent spending, there's not much of an excuse to have this DL (on paper) at this point in his regime.
  17. I think the Bears ended up with a solid draft, but took a questionable route to get there. Thieneman- full disclosure, I had McNeil-Warren as the better safety, by just a tad. That being said, I am willing to go against my gut and go with the consensus best player on the board at the position of biggest need. Obviously, he's a day 1 starter at safety, so no issues with the pick. Interesting though, Bears could have gone elsewhere here and still had EMW, who went 58. There just wasn't anyone better than Thieneman on the board IMO. Logan Jones- again, I didn't have him as my top C, but clearly the Bears did. Of course, my C1 didn't go til the 5th round (Hecht). I'm willing to get on board with this move. Jones was my C2, so they got consensus top 2 players (by most accounts) at S and C. The next C went off the board at 63, so there may not have been the ability to take him at 69 after the trade down. My only concern is you could have traded down from 57, taken Jones and 60 and maybe gotten a bit more in that trade down? Roush- I know a lot hate this pick, but in hindsight, I get it. TEs were coming off the board like crazy. 5 TEs went off the board before him, 4 of those within a 15 pick span where the Bears had the two 2nds. So, if the Bears truly identified Roush as their guy, and felt they HAD to have him, then this was the right place to pick him. Three more TEs went before the Bears next pick, and he undoubtedly would have been gone by 124 or wherever they picked. Thomas- It was obvious to me the Bears were going to take a really fast WR in this draft. Like TE, WRs came flying off the board at a record pace as well (most pass catchers in top 100 ever). But it's perfectly fair to question the pick and player. The pick, obviously front 4 was a huge need. And this was a real sweet spot for many of the DTs I liked personally. But the Bears didn't apparently. The player, I think if you wanted speedy, gadgety guy, there were guys like Brenan Thompson and Skyler Bell who were either just as fast (Thompson) or plenty fast enough (Bell) who are better at actual WR things. And then there were speedy outside guys like Bryce Lance or Colby Young who can fly and were better players too. Muhammad- no problem with this pick or player. CB getting some 2nd round steam in the last week or so. Got him in the 4th, CB is a depth and long-term need for sure. No issues here. You basically lost your chance to add any real DL help by this point anyway so take the best player out there, which Muhammad had a legit argument to be that. Elliott- again, the DL left wasn't going to move the needle any. Got him in the late 5th and was projected to go in the 4th or so. Depth LB. Only issue is that you just drafted a depth LB in the mid rounds last year with Ruben Hyppollite. Van den berg- I actually love this dude. He is very raw as a player, but he has elite athleticism with a 10 RAS and elite strength (35 reps of 225, dad was Mr Olympia South Africa). That strength just has to be more football functional. Definitely a late pick I can see making the team and outplaying his draft status. Good pick.
  18. Have you considered he's motivated?
  19. The only guy of my "almost certainly " that was left. Didn't expect that. I actually liked McNeil-Warren better, but consensus had Thieneman as a top 15 ish player.
  20. Players who will almost certainly be gone before 25. Fernando Mendoza, Jeremiyah Love, Arvell Reese, David Bailey, Francis Mauigoa, Sonny Styles, Rueben Bain, Caleb Downs, Spencer Fano, Monroe Freeling, Jordan Tyson, Carnell Tate, Makai Lemon, Mansoor Delane, Kenyon Sadiq, Vega Ioane, Dillon Thieneman My top options at 25 (mostly in order) 1. Ahkeem Mesidor 2. Emmanuel McNeil-Warren 3. Malachi Lawrence 4. Keldric Faulk 5. Max Iheanachor 6. Kayden McDonald 7. Chris Johnson 8. Colton Hood 9. Peter Woods 10. TJ Parker 11. Christen Miller 12. Caleb Lomu 13. Treydan Stukes
  21. Nah, WR should be surprising. Everyone says they're taking BPA, but best player available is based on a team's draft board. A team's draft board is heavily influenced by team need. So unless it's another Burden situation where a guy like Jordan Tyson, who they think is a top 10-15 guy is there at 25, they aren't going to take him. Like I don't see them taking Omar Cooper Jr even if they have him higher than an Edge, safety or LT they really like. Of course, they also probably wouldn't have Cooper that high to begin with is my point.
  22. Yeah, I never suggested to ignore it. In fact, my most recent post said the opposite.
  23. Theoretically. But those negative statistics with patellar tears are heavily weighed by guys that got hurt more than 7-10 years ago and are much older than Ozzy is going thru his tear.
  24. Trapilo is 6'8, I dont see him moving inside. The others, maybe you can put Proctor there, but idk about any of the other guys
  25. Starting to warm up to the idea of OT at 25. I previously said that an OT at 25, effectively ends Ozzy Trapilo's career, but that may not really be the case. I think there's a decent amount of snaps for Ozzy as the extra 6th linemen in short yardage and pseudo 13 personnel. Then there's always injuries. He wasn't drafted super high to where you are completely throwing away a super asset (56th pick) and gives you a really talented swing guy. But to be fair, I also believe he showed enough last year to where he could be the starting LT of the future and nobody would bat an eye. The Bears are in a better position on paper than they were at this point last year. Nobody was sure if Braxton was ready at LT. Theo Benedet was just the guy in the Speedo from 2024, and wasn't even thought to have a roster spot. Amegadjie was this ball of clay. Didn't have a pure lottery ticket like Jedrick Wills who they signed this offseason. And Ozzy had not yet been drafted. Yet the Bears didn't draft OT early last year. But to be fair, Will Campbell and Kelvin Banks went off the board before 10 and the next OTs didn't go until 29 and 32. My change of heart is due to the Bears not simply having the realistic option to go OT top 10 last year. Also, just because they got away with a hodge-podge at LT last year doesn't mean that's the ideal situation this year w/ a downgrade a center. There's also may be no Colston Loveland available at 25 who is a great prospect and perfect fit. So it's definitely something to keep on the table. The problem at 25 is you aren't getting a sure thing at LT. I do really like Max Iheanachor and Caleb Lomu who project to be potential options on the board then. But I also do NOT like Kadyn Proctor (who played at 380 for Bama) or Blake Miller, who I don't see with elite LT upside. Iheanachor and Lomu though are also big projections as Max has played football for only like 3-4 years and Lomu is super young at 20-21 years old. So if you gamble on those guys and they aren't ready to start Day 1, they aren't in any better off than last year, while also creating a potential log jam at LT of the future with Ozzy.
×
×
  • Create New...