Jump to content
North Side Baseball

raw

Community Moderator
  • Posts

    5,716
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by raw

  1. I didn't realize he has that much left on his contract. But how often are worthwhile trades made? What could you get for him, a 3rd and a average DE? Why not just keep him at least through 2022 and worry about filling the other talentless positions rather then creating another hole? Just my humble opinion, but it's a bad look for a one of the new FO's first moves to trade their best pass rusher, a franchise-record pass rusher. I'd be shocked and dismayed. Shocked and dismayed I say! Seriously though, if they did I'd want to know their plan to put pressure on QBs. I feel like there's not a good answer. The next regime is going to have to make a decision at edge rusher either way. If they keep Mack and Quinn at their current cap hits (combined about 47Mil) then that's going to make it difficult to build a team. Like has been mentioned, Quinn can be cut after 2022 pretty cleanly. But there's a big decision on Mack as well. His cap hit is 30M next year. If the Bears pay him 30M toward the cap, that says to me they are trying to get that big number off the books, and he'd also be gone after 2022. If they think he can retire as a Bear and still be productive for a few more years, then they probably should restructure and save a bunch of money in 2022. Could be looking at both gone after 2022 if no restructures. And if the plan is for both to be gone after 2022, then there's really no reason to pay them 47Mil toward the cap next year for a team that isn't going to be a championship contender. Gipson has played pretty well in a starter's role for most of the season. So, I have no hesitation to go forward with him at one edge. I'd probably look to trade Quinn. Even if you get a 3rd and 5th for him (Calais Campbell, Yannick Ngakoue trades from 2020), the cap savings (4.2M before June 1, 12M after) would be worth it in the long-term.
  2. I want a clean sweep. But I can't share that sentiment. Nagy is such a larger issue to me than Pace. If the keep Pace I'll groan, roll my eyes and then see what he does. Nagy stays, I riot. How many games were there this year when you felt the Bears had a talent advantage over the opponent? Yesterday and...Detroit? How many times did you feel they were at a talent disadvantage? This yeah was about as standard as they come for the Bears, as far as W/L goes. Basically, their record was pretty predictable on paper. Clearly better teams- GBx 2, Tampa, Arizona, LA Rams all losses, all by double digits Clearly worse teams- Detroit x 2, NYG all wins, all by double digits except the one on short rest with the backup QB starting They beat a really good Cincy team before they became a really good team. And they lost against a really good Cleveland team before they became a mediocre team. Other than that, Raiders, Steelers, Ravens (with backup QB), Vikings and Seahawks they went 2-3 against the teams that are similar levels of mediocre as they are, and the games for the most part were really close. Probably beat the Vikings and their backup QB to go to a perfectly mediocre 3-3 against mediocre competition. I believe the Bears are the same 8-8 team they have been the previous 2 years, but they just had a tougher schedule.
  3. Do they use the same tiebreakers as the ones they use for the playoffs? If so they’d have the same record, same H2H, same division record, same common games record, same conference record so it would come down to strength of victory which the Vikings are leading (current SOV for Minnesota is .436 Bears SOV is .354) Breaking it out even more, the Viking wins have a combined record of 13 games under .500, Bears wins have a combined record of 32 games under .500. Maybe possible for the Bears to catch up there but seems unlikely This is correct. Bears will finish 3rd in the division, regardless of result. Difference will be playing @ Falcons, home vs. 49ers and Texans instead of @ Saints and home vs. Indianapolis and Arizona. On paper, that's a huge difference especially when you factor in the difference of playing in Atlanta vs. NO's home field advantage.
  4. What's cool about Eddie Jak refusing to tackle? That is actually really cool. Fun fact: Eddie Jackson has missed ONE (1) tackle since Week 8 (I know he missed games as well).
  5. DeMar pulled a Mike Brown!
  6. The most predictable outcome to a dream scenario that played out perfectly in the draft. #OnlyMyTeams
  7. One thing keeping Leftwich from being my top guy is I'm not sure who would be coming with him. For one, the guys I'd probably have ahead of him would potentially come with a GM candidate as well (McDaniels, Roman, Moore). Secondly, the Bucs have a really good coaching staff but a lot of their top guys are older. Their younger guys are mostly unproven, especially in terms of being coordinators or playcallers. And Leftwich has only really coached under the Arians tree so it's not like he can pull guys from his past connections, unless it's from his playing days (admittedly, I haven't looked into anyone he may have played with or for). So, you're potentially looking at a 1st time HC, who will likely also have calling plays on his plate. You may get an experienced OC as kind of like a mentor, but I'd imagine you'd also get a 1st time DC since I don't see Bowles coming with Leftwich to make a lateral move. But I do love your 1st point, and it may be the most important when looking at the next candidate. Fields would be a fantastic fit with what Leftwich has shown he can do with an offense in the last 3-4 years.
  8. I may or may not watch every game legally or illegally on my computer, and have only missed 2 games.
  9. I know they have to trade for another big, but I'd hate to see anyone lose minutes at this point. Coby looking like 2000s Steve Nash last night. But I'd really hate to see guys like Javonte, DJJ and Ayo lose playing time if they add a big and a shooter, and go to an 8-man rotation during the playoffs.
  10. Purdy's draft stock went to hell. He was a potential 2nd round pick before last season, now has CFL in his future.
  11. Jake Fromm or Mike Glennon, so either way is a storyline. Also, a reporter as Saquan about tearing his ACL in Chicago last year, so I guess that's a storyline as well for a game desperate for one. Dalton practiced in full today. Fields was limited. Jenkins was full too, so hopefully Nagy doesn't F this up and we see Fields, Jenkins, Borom, Graham Jr, Dazz still getting snaps, etc. I wasn't planning on watching because was doing Christmas with the inlaws, but now gonna be quarantined, so I'll be flipping back and forth from this game to the Titans game.
  12. Difference between Leftwich and Nagy is that Leftwich legitimately runs the offense. Arians is old and just a figurehead at this point. He's repeatedly stated that Leftwich runs offensive meetings, with or without him present. Plus, Leftwich has played QB at the NFL level and was well known as a leader even from back in his days in college when he played thru an ankle injury and his OL literally picked him up and carried him down the field everytime they moved the chains. I'm not completely sold on Leftwich (or any other coach TBH) but it has nothing to do with Nagy, Brady, Arians or anything else. He's definitely in my top 5. the only comparison to nagy was in the praise coming from an established offensive minded and highly regarded head coach. i really don't believe that arians is as hands off as is being said here. and if anything, nagy (from what we were told and from what we could see from afar) was doing more with less as alex smith and their offense took a huge jump that year. and nobody had anything bad (especially not reid) to say about nagy as a leader prior to this season. if anything, it was seen as his one trait to hang his hat on even if he did suck at calling/running/designing offense (again, before this year). my "criticism" (it's not really that) is based entirely on the fact that i have no idea what his qualifications are - and having played does little to nothing for me. plenty of guys who played at the NFL level suck ass as coaches and plenty of guys who didn't are great. just about anybody who is a cromulent nfl coordinator should be able to coach that offense to success. maybe he'd be good, maybe he'd be bad - i'm just not sure what there really is to be excited about. I don't know what would excite you about anyone then (not that coaches are exciting in the first place). Nobody really is qualified to be a head coach, until they actually become a head coach. Even some with experience (Urban Meyer) turn out to be bad. I mean, everyone wants young offensive coordinators, whose offenses put up big numbers. Leftwich is young (41), has offenses that put up big numbers (with and without Brady) and you take points away because the offense has too much talent? I get your point, but he also has played a huge part in the development of Chris Godwin, who went from a good compliment to a probably 18-20M/year contract coming this offseason. Guys like Shanahan and McVay had similar resumes to Leftwich. Kellen Moore very similar, down to having tons of offensive talent.
  13. i'm assuming this is in response to me. it's one thing to have success with or without great players. it's another for your entire resume to be based on an offense that is bruce arians's baby with tom brady quarterbacking (and, yes, an embarrassment of riches at WR). no idea what the hype is about or what makes people think he's interesting as a candidate other than arians talking him up. it doesn't necessarily have to be the case, but we already saw how much that means with reid/nagy (when reid took the blame for all the bad playcalling and gave him the credit for the good and said nagy was the most HC ready coach he's ever worked with blah blah blah). Difference between Leftwich and Nagy is that Leftwich legitimately runs the offense. Arians is old and just a figurehead at this point. He's repeatedly stated that Leftwich runs offensive meetings, with or without him present. Plus, Leftwich has played QB at the NFL level and was well known as a leader even from back in his days in college when he played thru an ankle injury and his OL literally picked him up and carried him down the field everytime they moved the chains. I'm not completely sold on Leftwich (or any other coach TBH) but it has nothing to do with Nagy, Brady, Arians or anything else. He's definitely in my top 5.
  14. Yep. Raiders were my #2 team growing up. Though it was more after his time there, in the early-to-mid 80s, I loved the players that carried over from his era (Lester Hayes, Cliff Branch, Mike Haynes). He still had a huge stamp on that franchise.
  15. I just realized the Dolphins won Week 1. So they are the only team in the history of football to have a 7 game win streak and a 7 game losing streak in the same season.
  16. Doug Pederson isn't a bad coach, but I think would be very bad for the Bears. The similarities between Pederson and Nagy aren't enough to inspire confidence that the team would be going in the right direction. Both were Andy Reid OCs before becoming head coaches. While Pederson had much more success than Nagy, they basically run the same offense. This seems like more of the same for the Bears. Went from after 2018 thinking that getting the right RB for the scheme was the missing piece (traded Howard, drafted Montgomery). Then after 2019, they didn't have the right TEs or coaching staff (out Shaheen and Burton, in Kmet and Graham, changed OC, OL coaches). Then after 2020, it was definitely the QB and they had to get Dalton, who was handpicked but clearly not the exact same as the previously hand-picked QB the previous offseason. Going from Nagy to Pederson reeks of these type of moves but now it's the coach that's the problem. While that very well may be a large part of the issue, the scheme, the players and the player acquisition stinks. And I do think that's the type of hire that happens if you keep Pace. That type of move says to me, "hey, we're really close. The players and acquisition are fine. The scheme is fine. But the situational playcalling!" Down to the fact that Pederson was with the team part of camp this year, and guys like John DeFillipo was on Pederson's staff. It's just delaying the inevitable change that is needed in this organization. You can't tease all this change and then run it back with Doug Pederson. Todd Bowles doesn't do much for me either. He definitely deserves another shot, but I don't think Chicago is the right place for him. I have no questions about his ability to lead. I don't know that he has proved he has the connections to build a strong offensive staff. Meanwhile, I think Raheem Morris is out there and looks like a better version of him, IMO. Morris similarly had a 3-year HC stint with a (then) perennial NFL cellar dweller and had 1 really good year. But Morris has also since worked with Shanahan, McVay, both LaFleurs, and currently works with a bunch of potentially great young offensive minds in LA. Bowles works with a couple of good offensive minds, but he isn't bringing Leftwich as his OC. Morris is also 13 years younger.
  17. I was thinking about that as well. Its hard not to be "wins matter" and realize the circumstances that led to this one. I'm happy the Bears won, but still, horsefeathers Nick Foles Nick Foles is fine. He probably should be a Bear next year as well. They have to pay him 7.67 Mil for him to go away and only save 3Mil by doing so. Already guaranteed to spend 12.67Mil on the backup QB position, even if you don't have one on the roster. The 3Mil you save from Foles would likely be spent right back on a backup, who probably isn't as good as Foles in a pinch.
  18. Missed all but the Bears 1st TD drive in this game. Just saw the TD and 2pt conversion. Has there even been a single play made for Justin Fields this year where a receiver made a play on the ball as good as those two? Hell, Byrd and Graham dropped easier ones in the game last week with Fields' on the field.
  19. I can buy that Pace may be getting better at his job. I mean, after 7 years there should be things he's learned from and does better at this point. But even those names aren't THAT big of a deal that he's irreplaceable. The group is largely unproven outside of Jaylon and Mooney. Fields was a no-brainer. And all those names can be credited to scouting. You keep the scouting mostly in tact and that's not an issue. It's just really concerning that the organization didn't really seem to plan for this situation. I believe someone mentioned it, but we know Pace and Nagy basically had to campaign to keep their jobs last January. Why didn't ownership plan out a scenario where they could want to fire them again the year after, especially if there were no extensions involved? Now the potential Pres of Football Operation thing will delay everything. You can fire both Pace and Nagy without a Pres., but you can't really hire a HC or GM without one if your plan is to get one. I know they don't necessarily have to be in a hurry to hire any of these positions and there will be no shortage of candidates even if every team in need hires a HC/GM first, but if they do their true due diligence with all of these hires, you could be looking at going into the combine and draft season without a front office or a direction. If you want to keep Nagy til the end of the year, fine. But announce it this week so you can interview. Pace can be in on the interviews without making a decision. Use the last 2 weeks of the season to also interview team Pres candidates if that's the direction you're going in. He gets hired a week or 2 into the playoffs and has til the Superbowl to figure out what to do with Pace. From there go into HC interviews. Depending on who you have your eye on as HC, you might not even need a GM first. I'd imagine a guy like Josh McDaniels is allowed to bring in a Pats FO guy with him if necessary, so you can even cut that process down some if you want.
  20. Can we do this with defense building around Smith and Johnson? - 1 starting caliber ILB to pair with Roquan - 2 starting caliber CB (slot and boundary) - 1 starting caliber S - Rotational DL (ideally extend Nichols) CB needs some real talent additions, the rest could patch up with cheap veterans Maybe Graham Jr has taken the outside CB slot, the rest of our current roster can compete for the slot? I also wonder about resigning Hicks ILB should be easy to find on the FA market IDK what Graham could do to be given a starting spot next year. I think that's how you end up with a situation like this year. Ideally, if Graham, Vildor, and Shelley go into camp as your 4-5-6 CBs instead of Vildor and Shelley being numbers 2 & 3, then you have a decent CB room. I'd prefer to sign a guy with some flexibility to play inside or out, and then draft the best guy you can find in the 2nd or 3rd. Probably have to bring in another Burns or Trufant just in case you can't draft a guy good enough to compete since you have limited draft picks. But that signing could wait til summer. I would not touch Hicks. 32 years old, missed 11 games in 2019 and going to miss all or parts of like 9-10 games this year. Love the guy and he's a monster when on the field, but I'm not spending the money to keep a guy that old, that big, and that injury prone. Bad combo. Plus, he's one of 2 guys (Robinson) that could bring back a comp pick.
  21. Would be a Boxing Day firing if anything. That will work, after the Seattle game What if they win, though? Seattle is a very winnable game. They aren't going to fire Nagy after a win, unless they fully admit that they told him he was out this week beforehand, and that's still a sore spot with this organization.
  22. Realistically, what do we need to add for next year to feel like we're putting Justin in a real position to succeed? Something like this? - 2 starting caliber WRs - 1 starting caliber TE - A starting caliber Center - A starting caliber guard (ideally just extend James Daniels) - A tackle (these last few weeks to determine how good he needs to be) With the cap space open this offseason, that's probably actually doable? You're left bargain hunting on defense, but I'd be happy to finally have a team that can win games 34-27. I don't think they need a TE. Kmet is fine. He's like 15th in receiving for TEs. Sure he's not anything special, but he also doesn't really need to be replaced. He's fine and most importantly, cheap. You don't need a 2nd TE. Nagy running his 2 TE stuff isn't going to be here and it's not like the Bears are utilizing 2 TEs effectively. They went over 200 total yards for the backup TEs on the last play yesterday. Get better WRs and there's no reason to throw to the TE group more than they already do. I think I'd REALLY focus on the interior OL position. Re-sign Daniels, but you gotta get a stud inside. Whitehair is interesting. He's apparently very average or below average at this point, you could cut bait with him and try to find a better interior guy. But I'd probably be inclined to keep him around and move him back to C. Draft the best guard you can in the 2nd (yes, even ahead of drafting a WR) and build a strong unit that is young in 4 of 5 spots, and cheap in 3 of them. If you can get a legit stud C then you can do that and move on from Whitehair, but I don't think the Bears will A) spend 30Mil on the interior OL (Daniels, Whitehair, FA C) or B) trust a rookie to man the C position. I feel like there's so many avenues to add WRs. Cheap FAs, trades of Day 3 picks, middle of the draft. Probably bring back Jakeem Grant. Hope Dazz or the other PS guys develop. There's your 4 and 5 WRs. Add a FA and a draft pick and you're good to go. Don't even have to break the bank. Guys like DJ Chark, Devante Parker or Will Fuller coming off injuries would be cheap. Brandin Cooks could get cut or traded (for the 4th time) for very little. I'd lean cheap, short term over another Robinson type signing and develop a guy in this draft. Fields has had plenty of success throwing to Mooney, Byrd, Goodwin and Grant. If needed, have a 1st in 2023 to draft a true #1 (looking at you, Jaxon Smith-Ngiba).
  23. Even more critical because a President of Football Operations is probably going to have more rope than the subsequent GM and coach that are hired. You are giving this person at least 5-7 years to figure things out. Yeah, I don't necessarily care about the President role all that much. I'm not one to bitch about Ted Phillips. Getting the coach right is honestly my biggest concern. The right coach will maximize Justin Fields. If Fields is the stud we know he can be, the GM is going to look good and in turn, the president will look good.
  24. To be fair, he was pretty lackluster in preseason and training camp (from what I hear). But I don't know what Xavier Crawford showed and I know he doesn't have the pedigree of Graham Jr., so who knows the logic involved in that decision. Also of note that he played outside CB all night. Many people had him pegged in a slot role. So nice to see him handle himself well on the outside with a bunch of snaps against Jefferson. Bears played him outside all camp, so technically they kept Artie Burns over him, which I guess is more understandable w/ him being a former 1st rounder with a bunch of experience....but not like he had experience being good, and coming off a torn ACL.
  25. What? You don't kick FGs down 17-3 in the 4th quarter. 17-3, you need 2 scores. 17-6, you need 2 scores. You have to play to minimize the number of times you need to score when the time is not on your side.
×
×
  • Create New...