What? Leaving him at closer isn't exactly throwing in the towel when we don't have anybody better for the job right now. Camp and Russell posted similar FIPs and xFIPs last year and aren't exactly big upside guys themselves. Maaaaaybe Fujikawa, but I think it's pretty early to suggest that. As to the "sucks" thing, 2010 was his best year. 2011 was definitely respectable. And he was just fine after coming off the DL in late May last year. Is anybody expecting him to revert to his 2010 form? No. But there's a very reasonable chance he could look useful to a contender. Your argument isn't logical. It's purely emotional. Which is fine, I suppose, as long as you'd rather be making silly arguments than being frustrated. If there's anything that I've gleaned from the Soriano/potential trade saga, it's that even among executives, perception often trumps reality. Unless Marmol does revert to his 2010 form starting pretty much immediately, the Cubs aren't getting much for him. He was terrible for a huge part of last year, he was terrible in ST and he's been terrible so far int he regular season. DFAing him would be stupid, but I can definitely see the argument for pulling him from the cloer's role, at least for a while. I think his trade value is about as diminished as it can get.