How is having a lower career OBP by .049, a lower career SLG by .051, only five more career homers, and 161 more career RBI all in 1782 more career plate appearances considered far greater? Sosa's 162-game average for his career: .274/.345/.537, 43 HR, 114 RBI, 103 R, 65 BB, 159 K McGwire's 162-game average for his career: .263/.394/.588, 50 HR, 122 RBI, 101 R, 114 BB, 138 K I don't see how Sammy was "far greater" over his career. Using 162-game averages for McGwire is masking his biggest problem. Mac was a guy who either hit homers, singles or walked, and couldn't play a full season. One dimensional and injury prone. I think I built a pretty solid case for Sammy over Mac in one of the Mac steroids threads, but I'm not going to do it again. I'll just say that IMO, Sammy was more versatile, and during their respective primes, Sammy was just plain better. More XBH, runs, hits and a better defender.