His Milwaukee debut was at home against Colorado, but it wasn't a great start. Most pitchers dominate the bad teams and are average against the good teams...I don't think Sabathia is some kind of fluke just because he's excelled against subpar teams. Like you said, he's a very good pitcher either way. The difference between good starters and bad starters is that the good starters do incredibly well against bad teams, while the average/bad starters are a lot less consistent all around. I'm not trying to start a riot or anything, but if I had the time to look through Carlos Zambrano's starts, I think I'd find a similar pattern (if anyone actually can do this, it'd be interesting to see, and I'd admit if I was wrong). I do agree he has no business being in Cy Young discussions, though. He's a great pitcher and I'd love to see him pitching for my team. After what Yost is putting him through this year though, I'd want a ton of medical clearance on that arm/shoulder before paying him the kind of money he'll be asking for.