why? manning will be 36 next year and coming off a season that he didn't play because of a serious injury. even he would know that the colts would be foolish to pass up a franchise qb with the first overall pick. best case scenario, manning gets healthy and is able to be effective for another 4 years or whatever, but you can't count on that, not now. and if it does pan out that way, you've probably got two really good players at the most important position in sports, and should get a nice return no matter what direction you choose to go in. Because the situation is in flux, and they don't know. They also don't know if Luck will turn out or not. Manning is the Colts. I don't think I can recall a guy who is more the defining franchise persona than this guy. It's really complicated to just throw him away, IMO. I think this is a huge, very difficult decision. People are acting like the Colts just pick Luck, like it's a slot machine and you're just pulling the arm down. This is the guy who has defined everything for you, for his entire career. There's really not much else the Colts can even hang their hats on. Manning is it. Throwing him away like so much garbage? Wow, that's a big deal IMHO. I don't know. I'd be interested to see how a Colts fan feels about this I mean, if it's the Dolphins at 0-16, it's a no-brainer. There's nothing else to consider. But shuffling off a legend without even a chance to see if he can be the returning hero? Wow, that's big stuff in my eyes.