And it wasn't Kerry Collins that kept the Titans from making the Super Bowl last year. With weapons around him he's fine, but there weren't enough weapons last year. This year, the entire team is awful. We don't win 13 games last year with a more mistake prone QB, but I don't think there are a lot of QBs that would have taken us further. I think last year's team went about as far as the overall talent allowed. Sure, I doubt Brady or Manning gets much more than 13-3 out of last years Titans but if you put one of those guys on the Titans last year and you're thinking that team is a heavy favorite to at least get to the Super Bowl. Game managers are great and all but you need a QB who can carry a team at some point in the playoffs. On the right team a game manager can be part of a Super Bowl team (2000 Ravens w/Trent Dilfer, 1999 Titans w/McNair, 2005 Steelers w/Roethlisberger). Again, it's definitely preferable to have a better QB than a game manager, but the "game manager" tag is not equivalent to the mythical "gritty" tag in MLB. There is a value in being a game manager (not as much as being a great QB, though) while there is not to being "gritty." And by a QB taking the Titans further I didn't mean a better record than 13-3, I meant taking them further in the playoffs. Once CJ went down, there just weren't enough weapons for the Titans to win and short of Peyton, Brady, Brees or Rivers I'm not sure there's a QB who could have pulled that game out.