If you start taking out power to manufacture runs, there better be something else there that improves b/c that approach won't likely work under any conditions given the possible moves they could make. If Pie wasn't the best defensive OF'er in their organization, I think it would be a poor move, but he would be significant upgrade over Soriano right now. A Soriano, Floyd, and Jones defense is amazingly bad. A Pie, Soriano, Jones/Murton/Floyd is above avg. on defense. Over the course of the year, having Theriot over Izturis would help make up some of that diff. on offense at the expense of a throwing arm. They can't start playing small-ball and expect to outscore them while having a terrible defense. I don't want them to start playing small-ball, but if they did, they better bring some defense to that table.