Interesting exercise. Personally, I still think Brett can contribute more to a big league club than Vitters, due to D and baserunning. Not by much, but I think he'll wind up having a slightly better(still non productive) ML career. Although, the Cuddyer mention does lend SOME hope for Vitters honestly. Off that list though, I'd take Jackson or Vitters over the following- Rodriguez, Garner, Ha, Pugliese, Watkins, Loosen, and Peralta. I'm basing it off of if another team DFA'd Brett or Vitters, I'd trade one of those guys for either of those two. Cates, Rosscup, Szczur, and Andreoli would be iffy as well. The rest still have too much unknown for me to gibe them up for something I consider trivial. The reports on Rodriguez' stuff was pretty blah, Garner is a middle reiiever type, Ha is a 25th man type without the perceived upside, Pugliese is a decent arm, but the upside thing would allow me to give him up, Watkins does nothing for me, ditto Loosen, and I don't see Peralta ever putting it together. Cates and Rosscup both look decent in relief, but neither give me he vibe they're irreplaceable either. And neither Szczur or Andreoli are anything special obviously, although I do feel as if Andreoli has been overlooked a bit. Andreoli IS Szczur, except with better production and no hype because of his draft history.