Why is what Seiya was doing unsustainable? His OPS is now 40 points lower than it was in 2023 and 2024 so if anything he’s giving us worse production. Even when he was on fire his OPS was only ~30 points higher than normal. I’m too lazy to look at more advanced stats but at this point it seems like he’s having a worse season than expected cumulatively.
As for PCA, he had an OPS of .811 the last 50 games of last year so sitting at around .860 is a jump but it’s also his 2nd full season so what he was doing seemed somewhat reasonable even if it was a little higher than we dreamed. Certainly he’s not a .423 OPS guy which is what he hit in August.
Kelly was clearly the outlier. We’re really missing Amaya missing almost the entire season except for 1 random game.