well, we gave him 11 innings, time to pull the plug. No we gave him 3 seasons and 11 innings. I'm not guaranteeing that Castro is better from day 1 or anything, but for a team that seems to have a weak offense, you need someone with more range at SS. Also, Theriot's high average, no power hitting abilities were somewhat OK when the offense lead the league in OBP and runs scored, but in an offense with potentially 3-4 black holes in it (or possibly only 1 or 2) we need to start considering other options if there is a better one out there. the cubs aren't good, what's the point of killing an arbitration year and rushing a guy up to the big leagues when he is, at best, a very marginal upgrade from the current shortstop over the next two months? people complain that we rushed ronny cedeno; calling castro up now would be way more silly than anything the cubs did with ronny. Castro won't put us over the top, but giving up on the season on April 7th is a little premature. Especially when you consider that if you are even sniffing the race, the Cubs are probably upgrading in July. I don't care about arb years, since when do the Cubs have difficulty affording/resigning their star players when they leave their arb years. Teams like the Rays do that because they have a strict payroll. With the Cubs, if you can avoid an extra arb year, do it but it shouldn't be written in stone that it has to be that way.