I'm not sure where to find WARP stats for NBA players, but other metrics like win shares and PER are not heavily in favor of Anthony. I think you are really undervaluing Noah in this argument. There is not a player like Noah with all his intangibles on every team. If there was, Denver would have no desire to demand Noah in a trade for Anthony. Anthony PER 09-10: 22.2 PER 08-09: 19.0 Win shares 09-10: 7.9 (5.6 offensive, 2.4 defensive) Win shares 08-09: 5.0 (2.4 offensive, 2.6 defensive) Win shares per 48 mins 09-10: .145 Win shares per 48 mins 08-09: .105 Noah PER 09-10: 17.9 PER 08-09: 16.5 Win shares 09-10: 6.2 (2.7 offensive, 3.5 defensive) Win shares 08-09: 6.4 (3.8 offensive, 2.7 defensive) Win shares per 48 mins 09-10: .159 Win shares per 48 mins 08-09: .154 And obvious in 08-09: Noah was playing 24 mins a night, and in 09-10 Noah played several very ineffecitve games while struggling with his foot injury. Heck include Deng in the mix because that's who Melo would be replacing right? Deng had a 16.1 PER last year and 5.9 win shares (.106 per 48). Is the difference between Deng and Anthony worth taking an 18 PER center like Noah off the team? BTW there were only 6 other centers in the league that played at least 60 games and had a PER more than Noah's 17.9. Dwight Howard, Andrew Bogut, Andrew Bynum, Brook Lopez, Al Horford, and Marc Gasol. Tell me which of those guys we'll be able to acquire to fill the hole Noah leaves. If you can accept a slight down grade, there are 9 players besides Noah with a PER higher than 16.5, the 6 mentioned above, as well as JaVale McGee, Samuel Dalembert, and Chris Kaman. So yeah maybe you can get one of those guys, but its not like these teams are giving up players like that for nothing. After presumably trading Noah, Deng, and a 1st for Anthony, how much trade fodder do you have left?