Well thats basically what I'm saying. The 3 best teams in the NL are in the same division and will play anywhere from 4-6 games against each other to canabalize themselves into 1 team to play one of the lesser two teams for the right to go into the WS. Like I said, I'm not saying the system is unfair its just really unfortunate that it's playing out this way, but I guess this will happen on occasion. As for the seeding based on record, guaranteeing a divison winner a playoff spot would lessen but not eliminate the point of divisions. It's the same argument thats going on in the NBA right now, the major difference being that a team plays the teams in its division 3x as much as they play teams outside of their division (in the same league). That heavily unbalanced scheduling, to me, means that you have to give a heavy weight to division winners. But I'm not really a fan of unbalanced scheduling anyways (at least not to the degree its at now)