Here is a debate I've had with several people and I think it is an interesting question. Maybe it's a no-brainer, but I'd like to see where everybody stands on this. Here are the two options: You can have a guy on your team that walks every single time at bat. He never gets a basehit, but he has a 1.000 OBP because every time at bat he walks. Or you can have a guy that hits ONE homerun every game. He never walks and only gets one hit a game, that being the homerun. It could be a grandslam or a solo shot in the first. You can't choose when to use the homerun, you just know it will happen sometime in his 4-5 at bats. And I don't want any "Well, I'd sit the homerun guy until the bases are loaded, pinch hit and then immediately sub him." Pretend like you have to keep both guys in the whole game.