Curious to see if you can back that up. Mike Flanagan (started in '03, his first full season, same as Hendry) has topped out at 78 wins. Ed Wade GMd the Phillies for 8 years, never reaching the postseason, he then got a job with Houston after one year off and has led them to 0 postseason appearances in 3 seasons. Dan O' Dowd has been pretty terrible with the Rockies, but they've been superior to the Cubs recently. ETA: That's just current guys, and there aren't many that qualify in terms of having been around a long time with big payrolls.