At the risk of making goony angry: Greg Maddux Frank Thomas Jeff Bagwell Mike Piazza Barry Bonds Tim Raines Roger Clemens Craig Biggio Curt Schilling Alan Trammell There are probably 16 or 17 guys I'd vote for. Of the 17 returning players, only Lee Smith, Jack Morris, and Don Mattingly seem like obvious noes. Of course Morris finished 2nd last year and will probably inexplicably go in with: -the 22nd best bWAR among eligibles -8th best ERA+ (Worse than Kenny Roger and MATT MORRIS) -6th in Ks And this is just compared to the guys on the ballot now. All time he sits: -Tied for 395th in bWAR (With Bartolo Colon and Steve Finley) -Tied for 484th in ERA+ (with Denny Neagle, Tomo Ohka, and Dustin Hermanson) But oh, his case is based on more than just stats, you had to be there and see how he was different, you knew when you watched him he was a hall of famer. -Never finished higher than 13th in MVP voting (784th all time in MVP shares) -Never finished higher than 3rd in Cy Young Voting (Only received votes in 7 seasons, 76th all time in Cy Young shares) -5 all star games -Top 10 in ERA 5 times (never better than 5th)