I've posed the same question. When people say that Soriano should hit leadoff because he needs more at bats, or because he scores runs... it just doesn't make sense. With that logic, guys like Adam Dunn and Pujols would be great leadoff hitters, because not only do they fit those two criteria, but they also excel at the most important aspect of leading off: getting on base. First of all, there is no logical reason whatsoever why Soriano would only be able to produce hitting first, and not in the middle of the lineup. Other than him whining and pouting. And as I said, it didn't matter last year. Our entire lineup 1-8 (and sometimes even 1-9) was producing on a regular basis. Everyone was getting on base, everyone was driving in runs, etc. So it really didn't matter whether or not Soriano did anything offensively.