If he does that then of course it does not matter. The issue is the approach tends to cause players capable of doing great things to not actually do great things. If he somehow manages to flail at a ton of stuff outside the zone but still produce, good on him. The concern is that things even out. I envision Baez at around .270/325/465 right around 800 OPS. I think many people underrate him bc many thought he would be a superstar. But, I think he settles around those numbers with a versatile glove. And I think he's a very valuable part of the future. With his current profile he's gonna have to carry a .340-.360 BABIP to get to that slash line. Which certainly is possible but if he drops to a .260 or so BABIP guy that slash line gets pretty ugly