The only point I am trying to make is that we are not qualified, from this perspective to determine if an umpire if failing. If it was a safe/out call then fine, you can see that. With calling balls and strikes, you can't tell from TV. if you're watching every pitch from the exact same vantage point, you get a pretty good idea if the umpire how the umpire is calling pitches that appear to be 8 inches off the outer part of the plate. even if your vantage point is wrong you can still tell that the umpire is doing his job poorly. You may not be able to definitively tell if each pitch is a ball or strike, but you can tell where some things are in respect to other things. For instance, when Theriot was batting the pitch was right over the line marking the front of the lefty batters box. The pitch to Barden with two strikes was between the plate and the line marking the batters box. They were both in the vertical strike zone easily. Therefore, if the pitch to Theriot is a strike then the pitch to Barden is a strike.