I mean, you can agree to disagree if you want, but you're definitely wrong. Most everyone here would be very unlikely to go 1-25. The only hope many of us would have would be drawing walks or guessing the exact location for a straight fastball or changeup. I guarantee the vast majority of people here would be struck out on three pitches literally every time by major league breaking pitches. There is no way of proving this, so therefore how can I be wrong? Its a matter of opinion and my opinion is that most everyone here could go 1 for 25. That's simply a copout. It's my opinion I'd break the all time home run record in a year if given the chance. Prove me wrong. Fact is, if most people could go 1-25 against major league pitching, there'd be a lot more people capable of playing professional baseball. You breaking the all-time home run record in a year is not reasonable at all. Prove to me how a non-professional baseball player registering one hit in 25 major league ABs is unreasonable. Also, I don't see how getting one lucky hit in 25 ABs means someone can play professional baseball, thats an .040 batting avg. By the way, I blame this discussion on Aaron Miles. I don't think a large majority of people could. Most people can't react and swing the bat fast enough to catch up to a 90+ MPH fastball. Then there's the curve or slider that almost noone would be able to hit. Most people struggle with the 79 MPH batting cage speed and major league curve aren't much slower and major league sliders are normally faster than that.