I'd take the guy who's actually still good at football. Figured someone would say this and ignore the crap T.O. is playing with in Buffalo. Since Jauron was fired 4.75 catches 84.75 yards and 0.75 TD's a game. For a season that would equate to 76-1356-12. So you're expecting T.O. to have a 98-yard TD catch once every four games? Take out that outlier and he's averaged 4.5 catches and 60.5 yards for a pace of 72-964-8. T.O.'s had one 100+ catch season (exactly 100) in 2002. His last 1200+ yard season was in 2007 and his last run of three straight was from 2000-02. Brandon Marshall, on the other hand, is on pace for 106-1241-11 this year. In two full time years, he's had more 100+ catch seasons than T.O. had in his whole career and this would be his third straight. He's also on pace for his third straight 1200+ yard season. It's pretty clear who the better receiver is at this point, even if you can't see it. Marshall is better than T.O. at this point. Thanks for pointing out the obvious. However, this was about whether you would rather have Moss or T.O. at this point. Oh and 72-964-8 is about as good as you can get when Fitzpatrick is throwing the ball to you and you have a brand new OC midway through the season.