You are right. I know you didn't mean to be but working downtown where you meet a lot of people who live around New Orleans and talk to them everyday you learn about the city. I have been here almost 9 months and have worked at customer service jobs the whole time. I also went out and reported high school football and sat in crowd where many of them would still talk about Katrina and the city not being rebuilt. One of my roommates also has worked for the America Corps. out in the parishes for 2 years and I hear a lot about the people out there. SO yeah I would say I know how people in the city feel pretty well. Not as well as people who have lived here their whole lives but probably better than anyone on this board. Maybe, but maybe not. Do you actually think you know more about the city than him? Dude, he talks to people. I've never lived in New Orleans, but I've lived all but five of my 37 years in the state. I have a number of friends from there and have visited there a number of times. I met many of the evacuees in shelters, talked to one every day as she taught at my school until she returned home to rebuild her home in the ninth ward. He may have a better understanding of them than I do, but maybe not. Would my living in Chicago for six months give me a better understanding of the city as someone who lived in Illinois their whole life, but not in Chicago? I don't know, but I wouldn't be so presumptuous to claim it. Of course, I'd never claim I was mentally ready to be a parent at 18 either. In fact, I have two and at 37, I'm not sure I'm mentally prepared for it. But I guess we've all learned that da bum knows more than us anyway. You no doubt know more about the city in general. What I was saying is I have a pretty good idea of how the residents here currently feel. I don't know much about anything prior to my getting here. Although I will say visiting New Orleans for the first time one week before Katrina tied me to the city in way and caused me to read a lot about the city. I know how the people here feel at this moment in time anything else I'm sure you know much better than me. As for your analogy I would say someone who has lived in Chicago for 9 months would have a better idea of how the people in the city are currently feeling than someone who has lived in the state of Illinois but not Chicago for all their life.