I mean, they could be better that way, but it's also possible they don't improve your team at all with them. Choi vs. Lee. It isn't very similar to Choi vs Lee at all. We're talking about players with established levels of performance. We're also talking about pitchers who all have variance in year to year performance. But whether we are better off one way or another isn't the point. The post was a response to people saying we're essentially hosed unless we get an "ace" level guy. What is Brett Anderson's established level of performance? Guy who might be good if he can throw more than 22 innings? well, if you combine mccarthy and anderson, you get probably half of a pretty okay starter.