the key to the Cardinals success (and the last season+ of the White Sox' success) is health. All thing being equal, one might suggest that Prior/Zambrano/Wood/Maddux/Marshall + Derrek Lee and Aramis Ramirez is better than Mulder/Carpenter/Marquis/Suppan/Ponson + Pujols and Edmonds or Buehrle/Garland/Vasquez/Contreras/Garcia + Konerko and Thome The truth is, however, that the Cubs can't keep that combo on the field EVER while the other two teams seem to limit the injuries on their key players. The White Sox starting 5 started 152 games last year (with McCarthy getting the other 10 starts). When was the last time that Pujols was on the DL? Dave Duncan is head, shoulders, hips and knees above Rothschild and it shows in many aspects of the game. His pitchers don't get injured, he makes bad/mediocre pitchers better (Carpenter, Marquis, Ponson) while Rothschild takes all-star quality pitchers and can't keep them healthy or consistent (Wood, Prior, Zambrano).