Do you have a problem with every conference tourney winner making the Tourney in basketball? No because it's different in basketball. The lower seeded teams, with the exception of the No. 16 seeds, all have a chance to win in the tournament and it's usually not one specific conference that gets a 16 seed every year. The Sun Belt is the laughing stock of I-A football year in and year out. They're always the worst conference so why should they get an automatic bid? Not to mention the huge talent gap there is between the BCS conferences and small conferences in football and the same conferences (I'm talking about small conferences not one like the Missouri Valley) in basketball. This year has seen more parity in college football than ever before but that mostly pertains to the BCS conferences (obviously App. State over Michigan is an exception). Just as an example, the top teams in the Sun Belt, MAC, and C-USA are Troy, Central Michigan/Miami (OH), and UCF. Here is what those teams have done this year: Troy: Lost at Arkansas 46-26, lost at Florida 59-31, lost at Georgia 44-34 and beat Oklahoma State (5th Big 12 South) at home 41-23. Central Michigan: Lost at home to I-AA North Dakota State 44-14, lost at Kansas 52-7, lost at Purdue (9th Big 10) 45-22, lost at Clemson 70-14. Miami (OH): Gave Minnesota (last Big 10) it's only win 41-35, lost at home to Cincinnati 47-10, lost at Colorado 42-0, beat Syracuse at home 17-14. UCF (which probably has the best case out of these teams): beat North Carolina State on the road (last, ACC Atl) 25-23, lost at home to Texas 35-32, lost at South Florida 64-12. I don't know about you, but I don't really want to see first round games featuring any of these teams. Like I said, you want to set a provision so any non-BCS team in the top whatever-you-want-it-to-be get an automatic bid to accommodate 2007 Hawaii, 2006 Boise State, 2004 Utah, go right ahead, I'm all for it. But to just give them all automatic berths regardless of their record is a waste of a spot. By the same token, to give a 2005 Florida State and 2004 Pittsburgh automatic berths simply for winning their conferences is also a waste. but what a tournament like that would do is narrow the gap in talent between the BCS schools and smaller schools. if you were a kid and were being courted by a top Sun Belt school and a bottom Big 10 or Big East school, where would you go (knowing that winning the Sun Belt would put you in the tourney)? using the college basketball analogy, couldn't a tourney like this turn some smaller school into the Gonzaga of football? no one heard of Gonzaga before a couple of cinderella runs in the tourney, and now their recruiting is way up and they are perennial top 25 teams.