Tuffy is one of the best power hitters over there year in year out, but I wouldn't let that deter you. Although, as its been stated, pitchers usually work out better than hitters. I could be off on this, but I see him producing his first year in the majors something like what Abreu put up this year. He might gain a little power in subsequent years, but I don't think he'll be equal to Hideki Matsui. Well, that was kind of my point. Rhodes got an invite to ST with the Reds a few years back and didnt make it. So, if Rhodes can't cut it at the ML level (or at least not what he has done Japan) why should the Cubs consider paying a lot of money, especially in an offseason where it will most likely be scarce, for an unproven Japanese prospect? Because Japan is essentially AAAA. Some guys are AAAA players and that is where their ceiling lies. Others are able to adapt to a higher level of competition and succeed. Not every player that does well in the minors or Japan is going to do well in the majors. However, that does not mean that everyone who does well is going to fail when they take the next step. What you are essentially saying is that since Jason Dubois did well in AAA but failed in the majors then we shouldn't expect Felix Pie to succeed. Its a fallacy in logic. No its not. It is a lot easier to take the risk with Pie because, relatively, he isn't making any money. Can't say the same for these high profile FA from Japan.