You don't get credit for an I told you so, as there was nothing to say this was coming. That's kind of a silly attitude, imo. Obviously he thought there was something. was it his 1.19 whip in '07? his nearly k per inning throughout 06-07? him being in the top 10 in the NL in h/9, k/9, k's, whip, etc in 2007? which of those are indicators of a future collapse? This is just my opinion, but for me it was really a lack of a 2nd quality pitch (no one pitch rich jokes please). He had an average fastball combined with a very good curveball. On days he didn't have his curveball there was not another pitch he could go to. He couldn't challenge hitters with his fastball and that led to a lot of nibbling and control problems because he couldn't get hitters out with it on a consistent basis. I think things might have been different for him had he had some kind of a cuttter, changeup, etc. Also, I think once he went around the league more than once it was easier for others teams to approach him. They were able to wait him out and get him into counts where he had to come with a fastball. At that point they either hit him really hard or walked. I know you'll probably disagree because of your stance on Hill, but those were my concerns about him then, and now.