Maybe it is a cliche (I've never heard it), but it's certainly not true. Guys act out of character quite frequently. Temper is a big part of attitude, and people vary in their ability to control that. Desire can come and go, as evidenced by the frequent listless days players and teams experience. Exhaustion can negatively affect both your attitude and desire. This is especially true in a sport like baseball, which is a marathon. That type of talk might work in football, or lower level baseball that has fewer games, where you prepare for a limited amount of contests. But in pro baseball, attitude and desire will fluctuate throught the long season, no matter how macho somebody wants to talk about always giving 110%. I couldn't disagree more. An individual can always control their attitude and effort. Doesnt matter if you are professional baseball player, a teacher, auto mechanic, anything. Other outside forces are beyond your control, but you are the sole person responsible for the attitude/effort you will choose to have on a given day. It is an example I try to use with my pitchers. You can be out there and make every pitch possible, be hitting all your sports but your defense can let you down. The rest is beyond your control after that. You do your job. In my playing career there were a thousands of times where I would have liked to rip into my teammates, but you can't do that. Zambrano has had similar episodes. It s in situations such as this where control of your attitude and effort is absolutely essential. Control your emotions and keep on as if everything is fine, even if sometime it isn't. Like Ramirez, is some of his lack of hustle due to the sorry state of the franchise right now? Possibly. It shouldn't matter though. It doesn't excuse it. Nobody can make him do this, I personally don't think he will ever change. He is what he is.