I don't think 1 player makes a 15.5 difference in the standings. The Brewers are much better top to bottom than the Reds. before the fire sale, the Reds were not a bad looking team on paper. When they had Dunn, Griffey, Phillips, and Keppinger, they were an OK looking team, and add the fact that they seemed like they actually had some pitching for once. Who knw that Harang would fall off like he did.