The three you mentioned are and were better prospects than Vitters. A lot of people were projecting Josh to fall after a terrible senior year. How the heck does a team with our money let great prospects drop past us because of signability? On draft day, not all 3 of them were better prospects. Porcello certainly was a better prospect ("best HS pitcher since Beckett") and only fell to Detroit because of signability. Wieters arguably was a better prospect (but it was not a consensus amongst scouts; many questioned whether Wieters could stick at C and felt his bat wouldn't be as valuable if he changed positions...of course defense was and is a big knock against Vitters too). Parker was certainly not a consensus top 5 pick, there were a few knocks on him. He was an interesting prospect rising up draft boards and Parker was mentioned as the 2nd most likely guy the Cubs would have picked but on draft day but I don't think I saw any place where he was rated ahead of Price, Porcello, Wieters, Moustakas and Vitters. Vitters was held in high esteem by scouts for his successful seasons prior to his senior year and because he did well in the HS tournaments (especially the AFLAC game, IIRC) which scouts put a lot of emphasis on and came away with the excuse of down numbers his senior year due to the pneumonia. Whether those are good reasons to rate a prospect so highly is another conversation; those are just reasons why his stock did not fall during his senior season. To add to what CCP said, BA, BP, PG Crosschecker, etc. were all very high on him and they based many of their reports on what other scouts said. Vitters wasn't my favorite guy (admittedly, my opinion is based on reports I've read on the Internet; obviously I'm not qualified enough to argue the merits of various potential baseball draft choices) but he was a consensus top 5 guy - the Cubs didn't reach on him as they had the year before. Regardless of whether or not it's a failure based on reaching, or a failure on simply taking the wrong guy, if it turns into a failure, it's a failure, and can and should be held against those making the decisions.