Well, LaTroy followed up a 1.99 ERA over his last two seasons with the Twins with a 2.76 ERA during his time with the Cubs. It's not like he had failed miserably. This is exactly how stats don't tell the whole story. Despite Hawkins stellar ERA as a Cub, I think all in the organization and probably even Hawkins himself would say that his time as a Cub wasn't as good as that stat would indicate. Your points on Jones' contract I can't agree with. Calling his contract absurd is not a good way of establishing it. Compare his deal with the other FA Of's in his class and what they got and it is pretty much the same. Jones was an attractive FA if only due to the lack of quality OF available and the number of teams looking for one. OF was a limited position this offseason (and last one too) thus the market is high. Regardless we beleive that Hendry overpaid or gave too many years to Jones, the market dictates what he gets paid. Looking at the crop of FA OF available I don't think Hendry's deal was a bad one. Looking at what the Cubs would have had instead of Jones wasn't a good alternative either. In a vaccum Jones' contract may not be ideal but given the enviroment it was made in I think that Hendry afforded what needed to be done to fill that hole. Giles might have been the best solution originally but the environment plays a key role in the decision making process and Giles had the freedom to choose. We can't assume that if we had offered Giles more per year that he would have chosen us. Other then Giles, who would have been a better use of the money and/or years? And I'd also argue that fan impression doesn't tell the whole story, either. My point was that Hawkins' ERA made him quite tradeable. Especially if he was going to be traded to a team that wasn't going to use him as a closer, his value wasn't that low at all. When you're dealing with mediocre starting position players, there's a huge difference between a 3-year contract and a 2-year or 1-year contract. In my opinion, the Cubs would have been significantly better off paying $7 million for Burnitz for one more year, not tie up the hole in right field with Jones for three years, and go into the free agent market with some money to spend for right field. Jeff Conine (1-year, $1.7 million with Baltimore) and Jose Cruz Jr. (1-year, $3.21 million including buyout with Los Angeles) would also have been better options, depending on their health.