With every player mentioned, there are going to be people who like the idea and don't like the idea. Heck there is someone in the A-rod thread that doesn't want him for A-ram. It's just the nature of life that people are going to disagree about any topic, and that's doubly true for sports discussions. When you add to that, the fact that people tend to post more when they disagree than when they agree, you end up with threads like you mentioned. Happens on every message board. Not just this one. For example, try a video game message board, and mention whether you think a new patch feature is a good idea or a bad idea, and watch the fun.