patrick has been better. warren has done the same as horton essentially but over 40 more innings. Personally i feel like Leiter has been worse than Horton, but he has .4 more fWAR in 25 more innings so at the very least it's a conversation.
You'd think the narrative of Horton's insane second half would buy him some votes but I haven't seen anyone nationally giving a horsefeathers really so I'm not really sure it's penetrated voter brain, and by the time it does, if ever, he's probably gonna have one or two blowups that negate it in their minds anyway.