as far as what we need to do at the deadline or what we will do, there's probably multiple acceptable options you could convince me are the right move. Make a big trade to get a star, sure ok. Make some smaller trades because we're not *that* far off, you don't sell off the future and we can sneak into the playoffs and maybe get lucky, sounds good. Sell off half the team and start over. Yeah for sure.
The bigger thing is ... this team stinks. "They almost made the playoffs before cratering last year! They were good to start the year before injuries kicked our ass!." Every single offensive player has either stunk this year or has red flags (Busch K rate, Suzuki injury prone, Morel defense.) There's not one difference maker on offense. But that's to be expected because Jed built a defense-first team ... oh the defense has been ass all year too.
The starting pitching has been a bright spot for sure. But good starting pitching only lasts for a brief period because of health, and you really have to get lucky and marry your healthy starting pitching window to your good offense/bullpen window to truly be a winning team. This team is so far from a functional offense that by the time you build one the starting pitching will likely not the diamond in the rough it has been this year.
Compound that by the fact that none of the prospects look like difference makers at all. Not to boxscore scout here but one thing we've learned in the last couple of years is that the jump from AAA to the majors is bigger than maybe ever. These other teams are bringing their 1.000 OPS top 10 prospects up to the majors and they all fail. What level of confidence does anyone have that Shaw, Alcantara, Caissie, etc, are anything more than Wisdom, Happ and Suzuki, because we've seen what those guys get us.
Jed has built a mid team that can't even reach that level. No matter what we do at the deadline, he has to go, he's not built for this. And if he goes, whoever comes in is gonna gut this mess anyway.