Eh, he had a few good years. The comparison isn't really the problem, it's more that people think George was this horrible QB when he was mostly decent. I guess in that way he's very much like Cutler. Jeff George had a career 80.4 QB rating (i know, not a great measure, but the one with the most history--QBR only goes back to 2006), here's how that compares to some of his peers from his "era": Steve Young: 96.8!!!!!!!!!! Dan Marino: 86.4 Brett Favre: 86.0 Rich Gannon: 84.7 Jim Kelly: 84.4 Mark Brunell: 84.0 Brad Johnson: 82.5 Neil O'Donnell: 81.8 Troy Aikman: 81.6 Randall Cunningham: 81.5 Boomer Esiason: 81.1 Warren Moon: 80.9 Jeff George: 80.4 John Elway: 79.9 Mark Rypien: 78.9 Jim Everett: 78.6 Phil Simms: 78.5 Jeff Blake: 78.0 Jim Harbaugh: 77.6 Drew Bledsoe: 77.1 Vinny Testaverde: 75.0 Conclusions: Jeff George wasn't nearly as horrible as he's made out to be, goes to show that being a dick is much worse than being an average QB. Steve Young was unbelievable, Rich Gannon and Mark Brunell are underrated, Elway is highly overrated, Moon, Esiason, Cunningham, Simms, and especially Troy Aikman are overrated. For reference, Cutler's QB rating is 85.2 and that's tied for 13th among active QBs (tied with Cam Newton and Andy Dalton) (minimum 1500 pass attempts)--basically in George territory, and ahead of Flacco, Stafford, and Eli. Also, Aaron Rodgers is unbelievable. http://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/pass_rating_career.htm