Williams is essentially lucky. The Sox caught lightning in a bottle in 2005 and "rode the lightning" to the championship. (Lame Metallica reference). I mean, they really had 4 complete games in a row in the ALCS? From very average pitchers. However, you can't really argue with what he did in 2005 offseason either...at the time. Now, however, who would you rather have, Chris effin Young and Rowand or Vasquez and Thome? Also, the Freddy Garcia trade is looking good now because he's injured, but what happens if he comes back and is decent for the next 2 years and Gavin Floyd predictably sucks and Gio Gonzalez doesn't pan out? In addition, the Dye extension is kind of risky, and not trading Crede last offseason was predictably disastrous. Do you realize they might have been able to land AROD for Crede and Garland and prospects last offseason? Yikes. Their lineup for next season should be pretty brutal unless they make a huge AROD signing or something like that. If they re-sign Rowand, their OF could be decent (Fields, Rowand, Dye), but their infield will be in shambles outside of Konerko. Paying all 4 starters over $10 million doesn't leave them much room for change, either. Their bullpen should continue to suck because Kenny won't pony up for middle relievers. Overall, I would give Williams an A, for the simple fact that he ended a 90 year drought. However, for any organization outside of Chicago or Boston, he would get a C.